Top 10 Common Questions Non-Muslims Ask About Islam – With Answers

Many non-Muslims—both in modern times and throughout history—have had questions about Islam. Some are sincere, seeking understanding. Others are critical or even sarcastic. Below are some of the most frequently asked questions, with logical explanations and responses from trusted Muslim scholars.


🔹 1. Why Should We Believe in Islam Over Other Religions?

Answer:
Islam teaches belief in One God and acknowledges all previous prophets, from Adam to Jesus. It offers a balanced approach between spiritual and worldly life, emphasizing both reason and revelation.

Scholarly View:
Shaykh Ibn Baz said: “Islam is the true religion that Allah sent with Muhammad (peace be upon him), and it abrogates all previous divine laws.”


🔹 2. If Islam is a Religion of Peace, Why Were There Wars in Its History?

Answer:
Islamic wars were mainly defensive or to stop oppression, not for forced conversion. Islam prohibits aggression and commands justice—even towards enemies.

Ibn Taymiyyah stated:
“Fighting in Islam is not merely due to disbelief, but to stop injustice and aggression.”


🔹 3. Why Don’t Muslims Believe Jesus is the Son of God?

Answer:
Islam honors Jesus as a great prophet but rejects the concept of divine sonship, as it conflicts with pure monotheism and God’s transcendence.

Imam Al-Shaarawi explained:
“Saying that Jesus is the son of God contradicts both reason and revelation, for God is far above having a partner or offspring.”


🔹 4. Why Does Islam Allow Polygamy?

Answer:
Polygamy in Islam is a regulated exception, not the norm. It addresses social issues like widows, orphans, and imbalance in gender population, with strict conditions of fairness.

Imam Al-Shanqeeti wrote:
“Polygamy serves wisdom and societal needs, and justice is a condition for it to be lawful.”


🔹 5. Why Does Islam Prescribe Stoning for Adultery? Isn’t That Cruel?

Answer:
Stoning is a legal punishment with extremely high evidentiary standards (four eyewitnesses), making its application rare. It serves more as a deterrent than a commonly enforced law.

Shaykh Al-Fawzan stated:
“Stoning is a Shariah ruling under strict evidence, aiming to protect society from moral collapse.”


🔹 6. Why Do Muslim Women Wear the Hijab? Isn’t That Oppression?

Answer:
The hijab is a divine command that honors a woman’s dignity, encourages modesty, and protects her from objectification—not a tool of oppression.

Imam Al-Shaarawi explained:
“Hijab frees the woman from the gaze of desire; it is not a restriction but a liberation.”


🔹 7. Is Islam Against Modern Science?

Answer:
On the contrary, many modern scientific discoveries align with what the Quran stated over 1400 years ago—like embryology and the expansion of the universe.

Shaykh Al-Zindani in scientific conferences emphasized:
“Science confirms what the Quran revealed long before modern research.”


🔹 8. How Can Only One Religion Be True Among So Many?

Answer:
Truth, by nature, is exclusive. If God exists, He wouldn’t reveal contradictory messages. Islam confirms previous revelations and corrects human distortions over time.

Ibn Al-Qayyim wrote:
“Truth is one, not multiple. Islam’s finality confirms its universality.”


🔹 9. Why Does Islam Forbid Homosexuality?

Answer:
Islam promotes natural family structure and views same-sex acts as harmful to both individuals and society. It is not about hatred but about preserving moral and social order.

Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen said:
“Same-sex acts are major sins, contradict human nature, and lead to societal ruin—like in the story of Lot’s people.”


🔹 10. Can Non-Muslims Enter Paradise?

Answer:
Islam teaches that salvation is through belief in One God and following His final message. However, ultimate judgment belongs to God, who is Just and Merciful.

Imam An-Nawawi said:
“Those who didn’t receive the message are under God’s judgment. He alone knows their fate.”

Recent Posts

Congregational prayer

Congregational prayer in Islam is a vital act of worship that strengthens unity, increases rewards, and reflects equality among believers,… Read More

2 days ago

Muslim contributions to Science and Math

Muslim Contributions to Science, Math, and Medicine: Highlights from the Golden Age of Islam that shaped global knowledge continue to… Read More

1 week ago

What is the purpose of life in Islam?

What is the purpose of life in Islam? This timeless question has been asked by philosophers, thinkers, and ordinary people… Read More

2 weeks ago

Can Muslims have non-Muslim friends?

Friendship is a universal human need, crossing cultures, religions, and communities. For Muslims, the question often arises: Can Muslims have… Read More

2 weeks ago

A Dialogue with the Seeker of Truth

Me: Let’s start with the simplest question… Who created the universe? Him: Maybe nature, or the Big Bang, or some… Read More

3 weeks ago

Why Belief in One God is the Innate and Logical Truth

When a person reflects upon the universe around them, they find themselves before a perfectly detailed, harmonious system — from… Read More

3 weeks ago